Blueberry Muffin Creamer

Featured in: Cool and Quenching Beverage Recipes

Throw together half & half, blueberry syrup, a splash of buttermilk, vanilla, and a dash of salt for a creamer that'll turn your coffee into a blueberry muffin treat.
Lily chef cooking Cookingwithmee blog.
Updated on Thu, 05 Jun 2025 14:46:12 GMT
A creamy drink with blueberries on top sits in a white cup and blue-patterned saucer, next to scattered berries and a spoon. Pin it
A creamy drink with blueberries on top sits in a white cup and blue-patterned saucer, next to scattered berries and a spoon. | cookingwithmee.com

Started whipping up this blueberry creamer when I just got fed up with paying a crazy amount for dinky bottles at the store. The first round was kinda chaotic—looked like a smoothie bomb went off, but man, it smelled fantastic. Now it’s our daily go-to. Even my husband, who usually says store-bought flavors are weird, keeps checking when I’ll make more. Our kids call it 'purple coffee magic' because the way it twirls in your cup looks wild, like a tiny galaxy.

Irresistible Reasons To Try This

  • No Mystery Ingredients: You know what you’re putting in your mug every time
  • Simple To Make: Really, if you can stir, you’re set
  • Save Money: Costs way less than what you find in stores
  • Coffee Looks Gorgeous: Swirls make it selfie-worthy
  • Flavor’s The Real Deal: There’s no weird artificial aftertaste
  • Custom Sweetness: Make it as sweet or mellow as you want
  • Keeps Well: Should stay tasty around a week (if you don’t go through it faster)

What To Grab

  • Nice Touches:
    • Extra blueberry syrup (sometimes you want more flavor)
    • Pretty glass bottle for storing (makes your fridge look fancy)
    • Funnel, so you won’t make a mess pouring
  • Main Stuff:
    • Good half-and-half (look for the rich, full-fat kind for best texture)
    • Buttermilk—it throws in that perfect tang, just trust me
    • Blueberry syrup (find it close to maple syrup at the store)
    • Real vanilla extract matters (skip the fake stuff)
    • Small pinch of salt (sounds weird, but don’t skip—really makes it work)

Mess-Free Blueberry Magic

Chill Out Your Ingredients
Pull out what you need and let it lose some of that chill. Tried making this with everything cold and just got all these little weird lumps in my creamer.
Mix The Good Stuff
In a big pitcher, pour in the buttermilk and half-and-half. Sprinkle in a small pinch of salt. Give everything a solid stir so it all blends up nicely.
Pour In That Blueberry
This is where the color shows up! Slowly stream in the blueberry syrup a little at a time while keeping that spoon moving. Too much syrup, and you’re in for a sugar rush, so start slow.
Get That Vanilla Going
Pump in your vanilla extract. It makes it taste like it came from a fancy coffee spot. Stir super well—nobody wants all the vanilla hiding at the bottom.
Test The Flavor
This is your chance to make it just right for your taste. Mix up a little tester mug with your coffee. Add more cream if it’s too strong, or a bit of syrup if you want extra sweetness.
Pour And Seal
Carefully pour it into a clean jar or bottle with a tight lid. Use the funnel or your kitchen might look purple for a week.
Cool It Down
Let the bottle hang out in the fridge for a few hours, overnight is better. The flavors get super cozy. Sneaking a sip for 'quality control' is totally allowed.

Stuff I've Figured Out

Found out some tricks after plenty of tries. Let your stuff come to room temp so it blends easy. If you mix in real blueberries, definitely strain it—nobody likes chunks in their coffee. Scrub your bottles like crazy, or you’ll get soap flavor (gross). And maybe skip the white shirt unless you’re cool with purple splatters.

A mug of coffee with blueberries on top, surrounded by scattered berries, a muffin, and a napkin on wood. Pin it
A mug of coffee with blueberries on top, surrounded by scattered berries, a muffin, and a napkin on wood. | cookingwithmee.com

Swap It Up Your Style

Once you nail the basics, you can do whatever. I sometimes pour in a bit of honey and it’s extra good. Tried swapping berry syrups; raspberry is sweet, blackberry is more tart but still tasty. A friend puts in almond extract instead of vanilla—it’s totally coffee shop level. Whatever you use, remember, it’s easier to add more than take it out, so go slow!

How To Keep And Pour

This stuff stays fresh in the fridge for about seven days, but it tends to disappear way faster. Give it a quick shake before pouring—things settle at the bottom. A splash of it turns boring coffee into something fancy, especially in a clear glass so you can see the purple. Also, it makes a super cute gift—tie a ribbon around a bottle and everyone thinks you’re a pro barista!

Frequently Asked Questions

→ What blueberry syrup works best?
Most store-bought breakfast or ice cream syrups do the trick, but if you can make your own blueberry syrup, that's even better.
→ Why add buttermilk?
It gives the mix a little tang, kind of like what you get in good muffins, plus it makes everything creamier.
→ Is separation normal?
Definitely. Natural stuff likes to split up when it sits. Just shake or stir it and you're good.
→ Can I make it sugar-free?
Go with sugar-free blueberry syrup, though it might not mix in as smooth. Some sweeteners can be a bit tricky.
→ Why add salt?
A little salt wakes up all the flavors and keeps it from tasting too sweet, so you really notice the blueberry.

Blueberry Muffin Creamer

Bring a blueberry muffin vibe to your coffee with an easy creamer you mix from half & half, blueberry syrup, a little tangy buttermilk, and mellow vanilla.

Prep Time
5 Minutes
Cook Time
~
Total Time
5 Minutes
By: Lily

Category: Refreshing Drinks

Difficulty: Easy

Cuisine: American

Yield: 8 Servings (2 cups)

Dietary: Vegetarian, Gluten-Free

Ingredients

01 1/2 teaspoon vanilla flavor.
02 A little bit of salt.
03 1 tablespoon cultured buttermilk.
04 2 cups of half and half.
05 1/2 cup of blueberry-flavored syrup.

Instructions

Step 01

Toss everything into your blender and give it a good whirl till it's mixed up.

Step 02

Transfer to a covered pitcher and pop it in the fridge.

Step 03

If it separates, just stir or shake before serving.

Notes

  1. Lasts up to 7 days when kept cold.
  2. It's totally fine if it separates naturally.
  3. Tastes great in both iced or hot coffee.

Tools You'll Need

  • A blender.
  • A large pitcher.

Allergy Information

Please check ingredients for potential allergens and consult a health professional if in doubt.
  • Contains dairy.

Nutrition Facts (Per Serving)

It is important to consider this information as approximate and not to use it as definitive health advice.
  • Calories: 110
  • Total Fat: 7 g
  • Total Carbohydrate: 12 g
  • Protein: 2 g