Pin it
I first learned how to make chicken and dumplings with my grandma, hanging out in her kitchen while she shaped those little dough balls and plopped them into the bubbling pot. Fast forward to now—my own crew begs for this dish on every chilly night when we all want something that feels like a warm blanket. Butter, herbs, and a bubbling pot turn the whole house into comfort central, and puffed-up dumplings never fail to get everyone hanging out in the kitchen waiting for dinner, just like I used to do as a kid.
Dreamy Homestyle Chicken
This one's all about how simple ingredients can turn into absolute magic. The broth gets so thick and creamy, packed with bite-sized chicken and fresh veggies, and once those dumplings hit the pot, they soak up every drop of flavor. The other night, my neighbor smelled the goodness coming from my window, walked over with some bowls, and now makes it for her crew too. She says it takes her right back to her childhood kitchen with her mom.
What to Gather
- For the dreamy dumplings: Grab milk, plain flour, sour cream, melted butter, salt, and baking powder. Sour cream really makes them extra soft!
- Creamy magic: You’ll want butter, flour (to thicken), good broth, plus a pour of evaporated milk for that silkiness.
- Garden herbs: Fresh rosemary, sage, and thyme are best, but dried work if that’s what you’ve got.
- Soup starter: Chicken thighs cook up juicy—don’t skip the garlic, onions, celery, and carrots for all that flavor.
Soup Night Steps
- Get things bubbling:
- Grab a big pot and cook those veggies in butter first. It’ll smell so good as soon as it hits the heat! When they’re soft, toss in more butter and a bit of flour, then stir like crazy until it gets golden and smooth. That’s what thickens everything up just right.
- Layer in flavors:
- Pour in the broth, sprinkle in some fresh or dried herbs, and slide in those chicken pieces. Let it go until the meat wants to fall apart—while that’s cooking, you can mix together your dumpling dough so it’s ready to drop in.
- Last, dumpling time:
- Now the fun part—add scoops of fluffy dough straight into the simmering soup. Tip: Dip your spoon in the hot broth between each dumpling so things don’t get sticky. Close the lid and whatever you do, don’t peek until they’re done!
Pin it
Little Fixes You’ll Love
After making this forever, I’ve picked up a bunch of tricks. Never stir the dumpling dough too much—just barely mix it until everything is blended. Keep that lid sealed the whole time they cook so they get fluffy and light. Thighs really do make the tastiest broth, but if you swap in breasts, just keep an eye on them so they don’t dry out. Sometimes I stash extra broth in the freezer, so throwing together chicken and dumplings is super quick anytime we want it.
Time to Eat
We dish this out in big bowls (and sometimes I even go wild and carve out bread bowls for parties). Some fresh chopped parsley on top makes it pop with color. My husband’s obsessed with having crusty bread on the side for dipping up every last lick of broth. If the weather’s extra cold, a crunchy salad is our go-to side—it balances out all the rich flavors.
Leftovers are Gold
This soup honestly tastes even better after hanging out in the fridge for a couple days. The flavors get friendlier and the broth gets even yummier. Store leftovers in a tight container and you’re good for about three days. When you want more, just reheat it slow on the stove. Got more time? Freeze the broth part (before you add dumplings) for up to three months. Thaw it overnight, then whip up a fresh batch of dumplings and you’re set. My college kid always grabs a tub to take back for late-night comfort—says it feels like a homemade hug.
Switch It To Suit You
I’m always playing around with different combos—even though the classic is my go-to. After Thanksgiving, I’ll shred leftover turkey for a twist. Sometimes I add mushrooms or fresh corn in the summer. Last month my gluten-free pal loved it when I used her flour for both the soup and dumplings. Seriously, you can change this up a ton—the whole thing’s just waiting for you to make it yours.
Pin it
Soul-Soothing Comfort Pot
Chicken and dumplings isn’t just a meal for us anymore. It’s what I cook when someone’s had a rough week or when something big happens and we want to celebrate. There’s something about those soft dumplings in the creamy broth that just makes things better. Now my kids climb up on a stool and learn how to make it with me, watching as their dumplings float up for the first time. Passing on those moments means more than the food—every pot is a big bowl of family memories.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I make this ahead?
Yep, this soup is super for meal prep. Chill or freeze without dumplings for up to three months. Just mix in fresh dumplings when you reheat.
- → Can I use rotisserie chicken?
You sure can. Just toss in torn rotisserie chicken at the last step along with the milk and peas—no need to cook it from scratch.
- → Can I make this gluten-free?
Absolutely! Grab gluten-free flour and a gluten-free bouillon. Everything else stays the same.
- → What pot works best?
Pick a big wide pot, not a tall skinny one. That way your dumplings can spread out and cook all the way through.
- → Can I make this in a slow cooker?
For sure—let everything but the dumplings cook on low for 5-6 hours. Pop in dumplings at the end and crank it up to high for about 45 minutes.
Conclusion
You’ll love this easy chicken and dumplings! There’s juicy chicken, chunky veggies, and soft dumplings swimming in a creamy broth. It’s filling, comes together fast, and feels like a big hug in a bowl.