Buttery Steak Slider Buns

Handheld heaven awaits with these Cowboy Butter Steak Sliders - juicy chunks of beef topped with sweet, soft onions and gooey havarti cheese, all tucked between slider rolls slathered in tangy, bright herb-packed cowboy butter. Each bite delivers an amazing taste explosion, from the perfectly cooked meat to the fragrant butter that soaks into the warm buns.

I came up with this idea when hunting for something wow-worthy but doable for weekend guests. After trying different steaks and butter mixtures, this combo was the clear winner. My hubby said they're the tastiest sliders he's ever had, and now everyone asks me to make them whenever we throw a party.

Key Ingredients and Smart Shopping Advice

• Steak: Go for good quality like tenderloin, ribeye, or NY strip. Pick Choice grade or better for softness.
• Havarti Cheese: Melts beautifully with a smooth, creamy feel. Fontina works well too if you can't find it.
• Slider Buns: King's Hawaiian rolls are just the right size with a nice touch of sweetness.
• Butter: Stick with unsalted to manage the salt level. Better butter really matters for flavor.
• Fresh Herbs: Don't swap dried for fresh parsley, chives, and thyme - you won't get that same bright kick.

I've learned that giving the cowboy butter about half an hour to sit before using makes all the difference. This quick rest lets the flavors blend together perfectly. It really brings out the herbs and garlic, creating a deeper taste that takes these sliders to another level.

Step-by-Step Cooking Guide

Step 1: Get Your Steak Ready

Cut away any extra fat and silver skin from 1½ pounds of steak, then coat with neutral oil and sprinkle lots of kosher salt and freshly ground black pepper all over. Wrap it up in plastic and chill for several hours so the seasonings can sink into the meat.

Step 2: Whip Up the Cowboy Butter

Slowly melt 1 stick of unsalted butter in a pot over low heat, stirring constantly. Mix in juice and zest from ½ lemon, 4 crushed garlic cloves, 1 tablespoon Dijon mustard, 1 teaspoon paprika, ½ teaspoon cayenne pepper, ½ teaspoon cayenne pepper, ½ teaspoon dried thyme, and 1 teaspoon red pepper flakes, then take off heat and fold in 1 tablespoon chopped chives and 2 tablespoons chopped parsley.

Step 3: Cook the Steak

Heat your grill to medium-high with one cool zone, then let steak warm up at room temp for 30 minutes. Cook over hot flames for 2-3 minutes per side, brushing with cowboy butter as you go, then move to the cooler spot until it reaches your preferred doneness.

Step 4: Brown the Onions

Put a cast iron pan on the hot part of the grill and drop in a few tablespoons of butter. Once it melts, toss in 3 thinly sliced sweet onions and cook until they turn golden brown, stirring now and then, about 15 minutes.

Step 5: Put Together Your Sliders

Turn oven to broil and cover a baking sheet with parchment paper. Split the slider buns, brush with leftover cowboy butter, put havarti cheese on both top and bottom pieces, layer browned onions on bottom buns, add sliced steak, and cook for 10-12 minutes until everything turns golden and bubbly.

Pin it

My first try with these sliders taught me a valuable lesson about patience. I couldn't wait and cut into the steak right away, losing all those tasty juices. These days I cover the meat with foil and make myself wait the full 10 minutes, which gives me way more flavorful and moist meat.

Incredible Cowboy Butter Benefits

Cowboy butter turns simple foods into something special. The mix of herbs, spices, and aromatics creates a rich taste that makes everything better. The fat in the butter carries all these flavors around, while the lemon juice adds brightness that cuts through the heavy steak and cheese.

Pin it

Mastering Your Steak Skills

Great steak sliders need properly cooked meat. For medium-rare, pull your steak at 130-135°F since it'll keep cooking while resting. Using two heat zones stops burning while cooking evenly. The indirect method works great with a cast iron pan and butter drizzling.

Smart Slider Building Tips

How you stack these sliders matters for maximum flavor. Buttering and toasting both sides of the buns keeps them from getting soggy. Adding cheese to top and bottom means perfect meltiness everywhere. Putting onions under the steak helps everything stay in place when you take a bite.

Prep-Ahead Ideas for Easy Entertaining

Get components ready early for stress-free hosting. Mix up cowboy butter up to three days before and keep in the fridge. Cook onions a day ahead and warm them before assembly. Cook steak slightly less than you prefer if you'll reheat the sliders later, as they'll cook more during warming.

I've tweaked this recipe for years, and the biggest improvement came from playing with different herb mixes in the cowboy butter. Adding fresh thyme brought in an earthy depth that works wonderfully with the bright lemon and parsley. These sliders have become my go-to dish for casual get-togethers - fancy enough for special occasions but easy enough for weekend hangouts.

Tasty Side Dish Ideas for a Full Meal

These hearty sliders go great with lighter sides. Try serving them with a tangy arugula salad dressed in lemon vinaigrette to balance the richness. Sweet potato fries add nice color and complementary flavors. For drinks, go with a robust red wine or flavorful craft beer to match the bold tastes.

Pin it

Insider Cooking Secrets

• Get a meat thermometer to nail the perfect doneness every time
• Cut your steak into thin slices so it's easier to eat and spreads across all sliders
• Set up a butter station when serving guests so they can add extra cowboy butter if they want
• Sprinkle a little salt on your caramelized onions to bring out their sweetness
• Try adding a thin tomato slice or some peppery arugula to each slider for extra zip

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Which steak cut works best for these sliders?

Go for ribeye, filet mignon, or sirloin. Ribeye’s marbling offers a rich taste, sirloin balances price and texture, and filet mignon is incredibly tender. Skip tougher cuts unless thinly sliced against the grain.

→ Is it possible to make the cowboy butter ahead?

For sure! It keeps well for up to three days in the fridge or three months in the freezer. Make it into a log with plastic wrap, or store it in a container. Let it warm up a bit before use for easier spreading.

→ How can I check when the steak is ready without cutting into it?

Use a meat thermometer if you can—130-135°F is medium-rare, 140-145°F is medium. Without one, gently press the steak. Compare the feel to the base of your thumb when touching different fingers; each finger mimics a doneness level.

→ What can I do to stop the sliders from being soggy?

Toast the buns after spreading butter to form a seal. Let steak rest before slicing to lock in juices. These two steps help keep sliders crisp and delightful.

→ Can I make cowboy butter less spicy?

Totally! Leave out the cayenne and red pepper flakes, or scale them back. You’ll still get fantastic flavor from the herbs, garlic, and lemon. Feel free to add extra parsley or chives for a fresher bite.