Pin it
As Valentine's Day gets closer, you're probably hunting for something yummy and fun to whip up. Look no further! These Chocolate Peanut Butter Valentine's Hearts are incredibly straightforward to make. The adorable chocolate peanut butter heart treats just melt away in your mouth - they're sooooo delicious!
Being someone who writes about food, I always hand out my baked goods to folks who live nearby. But these DIY Reese's hearts? I selfishly hang onto every last one - they're just that amazing!
Key Components and Smart Picking Advice
- Smooth Peanut Butter: Keep it at room temperature for smoother blending
- Confectioners' Sugar: Gives you that perfect soft, chewy feel
- Brown Sugar: Brings richer taste than plain white sugar
- Chocolate: Combining milk and semi-sweet gives you the best flavor balance
- Vanilla Extract: Go for real stuff, not the fake kind, for tastier results
- Butter: Pick the unsalted type so you can manage the salt level yourself
Step-by-Step Making Process
- Ready Your Dish: Cover an 8x8 inch pan with parchment, letting it hang over the edges for easy lifting later. This way your peanut butter mix won't get stuck.
- Blend Peanut Butter Mixture: In a bowl, mix together room-temp peanut butter, melted butter, brown sugar, vanilla, and salt until the sugar totally disappears.
- Mix In Confectioners' Sugar: Slowly stir in powdered sugar until it's all combined. The mixture will feel thick and a bit crumbly but should stick when pressed.
- Flatten The Mixture: Push it firmly into your prepared dish, using a spatula or your hands to make a flat, even surface about ½ inch thick.
- First Cooling Stage: Stick it in the freezer until it's solid enough to cut shapes, about 30-45 minutes. It needs to be cold to keep its form when cutting.
- Cut Out Hearts: Put parchment on a tray. With a small heart cookie cutter, shape hearts from the cold mixture and place them on your tray.
- Don't Waste Any: Collect the leftovers, squish them together, flatten them out and cut more hearts. Every bit of that tasty peanut butter mix counts!
- Back To The Freezer: Return your hearts to the freezer until they're super firm, around 15-20 minutes. This key step stops hearts from losing shape or breaking apart during dipping.
- Get Ready For Coating: Melt your chocolate using a microwave (30 seconds at a time, stirring between) or a double boiler. Put parchment on another tray.
- Coat With Chocolate: Working with just a couple hearts at once (keeping others frozen), dunk each heart in melted chocolate using a fork. Gently tap the fork to shake off extra chocolate.
Pin it
I found out how crucial keeping the hearts frozen was when my first try turned into shapeless lumps rather than cute hearts when they touched the warm chocolate!
Wonderful Valentine's Day Presents
These chocolate-covered goodies make thoughtful homemade gifts that really show you care. Pop them in small bakery boxes with ribbon, or stack them in mason jars dressed up with colorful tape. Your kids' teachers, office pals, and folks next door will like these way more than store candy, showing real thoughtfulness through your handmade sweet treats.
Pin it
Fun Valentine's Activity With Kids
Kids totally enjoy helping make these peanut butter hearts! They can join in mixing, pressing, and decorating. Bigger kids can aid with cutting shapes, while little ones have fun putting sprinkles on before the chocolate gets hard. It's a tasty way to build family memories while teaching basic cooking know-how they'll always remember.
Adjustable For Special Diets
These treats can easily match different food needs. Switch to sunflower seed butter if peanuts are a problem, grab dairy-free chocolate for vegan folks, or try monk fruit sweetener to cut down on sugar. They're naturally gluten-free and fit most special diets while keeping that amazing chocolate-nutty combo everybody wants.
Do-Ahead Time Management
You can fix these hearts weeks before Valentine's Day and tuck them in the freezer. Getting them done early cuts out last-minute rushing and means you've got homemade goodies ready when you need them. They thaw quickly and still taste perfect, so they're great for surprise Valentine's celebrations or when someone drops by unexpectedly.
Pin it
Closing Thoughts
These Chocolate Peanut Butter Valentine's Hearts have turned into my go-to seasonal treat. I've changed them up for other holidays - Easter eggs, Christmas trees, and now Valentine's hearts. There's something really rewarding about turning basic ingredients into something that looks fancy but tastes way better than anything from a shop.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Will natural PB work for this?
- Stick with regular smooth PB. The natural kind often splits and won't give you the right feel.
- → Which chocolate should I pick?
- Try mixing semi-sweet with milk chocolate, or go for candy melts if you want easier dipping.
- → Can I make these days before?
- You bet - they'll last two weeks in your fridge or up to 3 months frozen.
- → Can I try different shapes?
- For sure! Any small cutter works great for other holidays or events.
- → My mix is too gooey to handle?
- Just mix in more powdered sugar bit by bit until it's firm enough to work with.