
This fancy breakfast brings together beautifully poached eggs, herb-infused yogurt and a spicy butter drizzle for a truly special morning treat. With roots in Turkish cooking, this dish turns basic ingredients into something extraordinary, showing how unexpected pairings often create the tastiest meals. I first tried this at a neighborhood café and couldn't believe how wonderfully yogurt worked with eggs.
I made this recently for some doubtful friends who couldn't picture eggs paired with yogurt, but they were instantly converted. The mix of cool, garlicky yogurt underneath soft eggs topped with warm spiced butter makes for a breakfast you won't forget.
Key Ingredients and Shopping Guidance
- Greek Yogurt - Choose whole milk variety for creamiest results
- Fresh Eggs - Newer eggs hold together better when poaching
- Fresh Herbs - Traditional choices include dill and mint
- Garlic - Just a tiny bit keeps it from taking over
- Quality Butter - Get unsalted and let it sit out first
What makes this dish so special is when the hot spiced butter hits those runny yolks and mixes with the cool herby yogurt layer below.
Step-by-Step Cooking Guide
- Step 1: Mix Up Herby Yogurt
- Take 1 cup of Greek yogurt and mix in half a minced garlic clove. Toss in finely chopped dill and mint, then stir everything together gently. Add a pinch of salt and pepper, then set aside at room temp while you work on the eggs.
- Step 2: Get Ready to Poach
- Pour water about 4 inches deep into a pot and heat until it's just barely boiling. Add a tablespoon of white vinegar to help the egg whites stick together. Make a swirling motion with your spoon to create a whirlpool in the middle.
- Step 3: Cook First Egg
- Break an egg into a small dish to check if the yolk is good. Slowly tip the egg into the middle of your water whirlpool, letting the swirling water wrap the white around the yolk. Let it cook for 3 minutes exactly, keeping the water at a gentle simmer.
- Step 4: Take Out and Do Next One
- Lift the egg carefully with a slotted spoon and let extra water drain off. Put it on a plate lined with paper towels to soak up water. Make another whirlpool and do the same thing with your second egg.
- Step 5: Prepare Hot Butter Mix
- Heat butter in a small pan over medium heat until it bubbles. Throw in smoked paprika and chili flakes, stirring them together. Cook for just 30 seconds so spices release flavor without burning.
- Step 6: Spread Your Base
- Smooth the yogurt mixture onto your serving plate in a circle. Make a little dip in the middle to hold the eggs. Make sure it's thick enough to support the eggs properly.
- Step 7: Put It All Together
- Carefully place your poached eggs in the middle of the yogurt base. You can poke the yolks lightly if you want them to start running. Right away pour your hot spiced butter over everything.
- Step 8: Add Final Touches
- Scatter more fresh herbs on top for extra color and flavor. Add some freshly cracked black pepper and a bit of flaky salt. Serve right away while you've got those nice temperature differences.

Mastering the Poach
Getting this dish right really depends on nailing those poached eggs. You'll want the freshest eggs possible and need to create that spinning water effect. When your egg drops into the swirling water, it helps wrap the white neatly around the yolk, giving you that classic poached egg look.
Playing with Hot and Cold
What really makes this dish stand out is how the temperatures play together. You need each part at just the right heat when served - yogurt should be cool and smooth, eggs warm with soft, runny centers, and the butter mixture should hit the plate still sizzling hot.

Not Just for Morning
Though many folks think of this as breakfast food, it works amazingly well any time of day. Try it for brunch, lunch or when you want a light dinner. Grab some crusty bread to mop up all those tasty sauces, or add a simple salad on the side to make it a full meal.
Pro Kitchen Advice
- Make sure your water spins properly for best egg shape
- Go easy on the garlic so it doesn't overpower
- Let your butter come to room temp first
- Get everything prepared before you start poaching
- Don't wait to serve or you'll lose the temperature magic

These Turkish eggs have become my favorite when I want to wow guests at brunch. The way common ingredients come together feels both unique and comforting at the same time.
Last-Minute Pointers
- Always pick the newest eggs you can find
- Make it as mild or spicy as you like
- Keep bread handy for soaking up sauce
- Think about making more butter sauce than you need
- Don't skimp on the fresh herbs for garnish
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What's the secret to good poached eggs?
- Pick the freshest eggs, swirl the water before dropping them in, and skip adding any salt.
- → Is there a way to make it milder?
- Absolutely, just use sweet paprika instead of the hot chili flakes.
- → Which yogurt should I buy?
- Go for thick Turkish or Greek yogurt for the creamiest results.
- → Can I do any prep work earlier?
- You can mix up the herbed yogurt beforehand, but cook the eggs and warm the butter right before serving.
- → What goes well on the side?
- Crusty bread works great for soaking up all the runny yolk and sauces.