Pin it
This dish comes from a neighbor who cooks Indian food that always wows me. What makes it special? Juicy chicken in a silky sauce full of cozy spices, creamy coconut milk, and just the right kick to light up your taste buds. We always crave it when we want something soothing. It’s on our table in under an hour and never fails to cheer us up.
Outstanding Every Single Time
Each bite gives you a punch of flavor—sweet onions, spice that hugs, coconut cream, and zippy lemon. The sauce gets thick and velvety, perfect for scooping up with soft rice or naan. These aren’t fancy ingredients, but together, they turn out like something you’d grab from your favorite takeout spot.
Grab These Things
- Creamy Stuff: Greek yogurt (the thick kind), coconut milk, and a tiny bit of sugar for balance.
- For Flavor: Onions (sweet ones hit best), garlic, tomato paste, a fresh squeeze of lemon juice.
- Your Chicken: Go with boneless skinless thighs, or swap in breast if that’s your jam.
- Spicy Layer: Pick up curry powder, cinnamon, ground paprika, a knob of ginger, and toss in a bay leaf if you’ve got one.
Time To Cook
- The Finishing Play
- Squeeze in lemon juice, stir in cayenne (as much as you’re feeling), then tweak it till it tastes just right for you.
- Get It Bubbling
- Dial down the stove and let everything gently simmer for about 25 minutes so your sauce thickens up and chicken turns juicy.
- Layer The Flavors
- Heat oil, cook your onions, throw in the garlic and all the spices, and wait for those smells to fill your place.
- Build It Up
- Toss in chicken and let it soak up all that spiciness, then add tomato paste, yogurt, and coconut milk.
Pin it
Pro Kitchen Moves
Drop in some garam masala if it’s handy makes everything pop more. Stir it low when you put in yogurt so it stays creamy. Want extra sauce? Pour in more coconut milk. If you need a hearty meal, potatoes or peas are perfect to toss in too.
Finish Strong
Spoon it onto soft naan or heap it over hot jasmine rice. Try cooling it off with a dollop of cucumber raita or bring some zing with mango chutney. Skipping carbs? Cauliflower rice works great and soaks up all the goodness, too.
Keep For Later
This only gets tastier after a day in the fridge—it needs time to chill and blend flavors. It’ll last four days in a sealed container and freezes for four months. When you’re ready, gently reheat—add a little coconut milk if the sauce feels thick.
Switch Things Up
Toss in any veggies you like—carrots, peppers, or whatever’s fresh. Like it hotter? More cayenne. Want it mellow? Leave it out. Use breast in chunks or leave thighs whole; both work. The sauce does what you need!
Pin it
Make It Your Way
Have fun with those spices—try extra ginger or take down the heat if that’s your style. My kids want more sauce for scooping up rice, while my partner packs in fresh chilies. It’s all about you and what makes you smile at the table.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Which curry powder do I grab?
- Really, any mild or medium curry powder is fine. Madras adds more kick. Start with less, taste, and add more if you want.
- → Can chicken thighs work instead of breast?
- Absolutely, thighs get even juicier. Just give them a few extra minutes so they're cooked through.
- → What if I don't have coconut milk?
- Try heavy cream or go with extra yogurt. It won't taste the same, but it'll still be good. Coconut milk gives that sweet rich vibe.
- → What do I pair this with?
- Scoop it over fluffy rice or tear up some warm naan. Quinoa and cauliflower rice are awesome, too. Throw in a quick veg side if you're feeling it.
- → Can I cook this the day before?
- Yep — tastes even richer on day two. Pop it in the fridge up to three days. Just warm it gently so the yogurt stays smooth.