Pin it
These soft, disappear-in-your-mouth treats go by various names worldwide, but no matter what you call them, their rich buttery feel and powdered sugar outer layer make them absolutely tempting. My grandma dubbed them Sugar Butter Balls, and they've been a cherished element of my family's festive customs for many years.
During our last Christmas gathering, I brought these to a cookie swap, and before the evening wrapped up, three guests wanted to know how to make them! That winning mix of buttery cookie and sweet powdered sugar outer layer really hooks everyone.
Key Components and Shopping Advice
- Butter - Grab unsalted butter left out to soften for easier mixing
- Powdered Sugar - Gives the dough a soft bite and smooth coating without any sugar grains
- Vanilla Extract - Stick with real instead of artificial for tastier results
- All-Purpose Flour - Forms the foundation of this straightforward cookie mix
- Nuts - Tiny bits of pecans or walnuts boost the overall taste and texture
The real transformation happens when you roll hot cookies in powdered sugar, making a sweet layer that just melts away as you bite into it.
Step-by-Step Baking Guide
- Step 1: Mix Your Dough
- Beat the soft butter with powdered sugar and vanilla until it's airy and smooth. Slowly blend in flour and salt, stirring just enough to combine without toughening the dough. Carefully fold in the finely chopped nuts so they're evenly spread throughout.
- Step 2: Form Your Cookies
- Take small 1-inch chunks of dough and roll them between your hands to make perfect little balls. Set them on a paper-lined cookie sheet about an inch apart—they won't grow much while baking.
- Step 3: Bake To Perfection
- Cook at 400°F for 10-12 minutes until they're done but not brown. They should feel solid when touched but stay light-colored. Don't let them go too long or they'll end up dry—keep a close eye on them.
- Step 4: First Sugar Coating
- Let the cookies sit for just a minute or two after baking, then gently coat each warm cookie in powdered sugar. The heat helps that first sugar layer stick and partly blend into the surface.
- Step 5: Let Them Rest
- Put the sugar-covered cookies on a rack and wait until they cool down completely. This waiting period matters before you add more sugar.
- Step 6: Add More Sugar
- Once totally cool, roll the cookies in powdered sugar again once or twice to create that classic snowy look. This second layer sticks better to cool cookies and makes the perfect sweet outer coating.
Pin it
Rich Heritage Behind Classic Treats
These cookies hold special meaning across many cultures. Whether they're known as Russian Tea Cakes in Eastern Europe or Polvorones in Mexico, they often show up at weddings and parties as symbols of purity and happiness. The white sugar coating stands for fresh starts, making them fitting for holiday get-togethers when we look back on the past year and dream about what's coming next.
Wonderful Gift Ideas
Not many homemade treats get the same warm welcome as these cookies. I pack them in pretty tins with colorful tissue paper, creating lovely holiday gifts that seem so personal and caring. The cookies travel nicely without crumbling and stay good for several days, so they're great for mailing to family far away or taking to holiday parties.
Pin it
Sweet Moments From Years Gone By
My oldest memories of these cookies involve watching my grandma's hands—tender but quick—forming each ball just right. I'd stand close by, waiting for when she'd give me a little wink and sneak me a warm cookie. That amazing melt-away feeling followed by the inevitable cloud of sugar that made us crack up remains one of my most treasured childhood memories.
Family Twists Through The Years
Though my grandma's way of making them is still my favorite, I've come across so many different versions from friends and relatives. Some folks add a touch of cinnamon or almond flavor, others mix in lemon zest for extra punch. Mexican styles often include anise seed for a mild licorice taste. Each household tweaks the recipe to match their likes, creating their own special version that gets handed down to kids and grandkids.
Important Reminders
- Handle the dough gently or your cookies will end up hard
- Cook just until done - they shouldn't turn brown at all
- Cover with powdered sugar while they're still hot for the first layer
- Wait until fully cooled before adding the last sugar coating
- Keep in a sealed container so they stay fresh longer
I found out how crucial careful handling is after my first try at age 18, when I thought I could just toss the cookies in a bag with sugar instead of rolling each one by hand. Half of them broke! My grandma's technique of individually coating each cookie really does work best.
Pro Baker Shortcuts
- Cut nuts into tiny pieces for better texture
- Scoop flour with a spoon into measuring cups instead of dipping
- Make sure butter isn't cold when you start mixing
- Cool cookies just 1-2 minutes before adding sugar - not too much
- For parties, mix a tiny bit of food coloring into the sugar to match your theme
Pin it
These Mexican Wedding Cookies have turned into my go-to holiday treat. Every season, my friends and family look forward to seeing them on my cookie plates or getting them as gifts. The steps are so basic that I can make them with my kids, keeping the tradition going just like my grandma did with me.
Last-Minute Advice
- Cook extra - they won't last long!
- Keep at room temp in a sealed container up to seven days
- Put plain cookies in the freezer for up to 3 months
- When giving as gifts, put parchment between layers so they don't stick
- Enjoy with hot tea or coffee to balance their sweetness
Frequently Asked Questions
- → What nuts should I use?
- Most folks go with pecans, but you can totally swap in walnuts too.
- → Why do I need to add sugar twice?
- The warm cookies grab the first sugar layer, and the second coating makes them look pretty.
- → Can I make these ahead and freeze?
- You bet - they'll keep in the freezer up to 3 months. Just add the final sugar after thawing.
- → What's the story behind the name?
- They've been a staple at Mexican celebrations and weddings forever because they look so festive.
- → How small should I chop my nuts?
- Go for tiny pieces but not powder - you want little bits that spread throughout the dough.