Pin it
Mixing velvety mac and cheese with zesty honey pepper chicken creates a mind-blowing comfort dish. Every component, from the crunchy chicken to the decadent cheese mixture, works together to mirror this fan-favorite Applebee's meal that'll quickly become your household's go-to dinner.
I found out that letting the honey pepper mix bubble away for a full 15 minutes is key to getting that authentic Applebee's sticky coating. Just last month, my kids asked for this instead of dining out on their birthday - that's how close this homemade version comes to the real thing.
Key Components and Shopping Advice
- Pasta: Pick grooved cavatappi or elbows that trap sauce in every twist. Fresh works amazingly, though dried holds its shape better for tomorrow's lunch
- Cheese Mix: Grab blocks and grate them yourself for the creamiest results. Mixing sharp cheddar, mozzarella, and Parmesan gives you layered flavors
- Chicken: Look for pieces of similar thickness so they cook evenly. If buying ready-made, go for plain strips so they'll soak up more honey pepper goodness
- Heavy Cream: Don't skimp on fat content for the smoothest sauce. Skip lighter options like half-and-half or milk entirely
Step-by-Step Cooking Guide
- 1. Getting the Chicken Ready
- Sprinkle chicken strips with salt and pepper. Warm oil to 350°F in a big skillet. Fry pieces for 4-5 minutes each side until golden and hitting 165°F inside. Move to a wire rack to keep them crispy. The raised position stops the bottom from turning soft.
- 2. Whipping Up Honey Pepper Sauce
- Mix sauce stuff in a pot over medium flame. Keep an eye on it as it starts to bubble - honey can quickly foam over. Turn heat down right away and keep at a lazy simmer. Give it a stir every few minutes so nothing sticks. It's done when it coats your spoon nicely.
- 3. Nailing the Pasta
- Boil pasta in very salty water until barely tender. Save a cup of cooking water before draining. Don't rinse - that starch helps the sauce stick. Toss pasta with a bit of olive oil in the pot to stop clumping.
- 4. Creating Cheese Sauce
- Begin with butter and cream, warming them gently to avoid splitting. Toss in cheeses bit by bit, stirring non-stop. If it gets too thick, splash in some pasta water a spoonful at a time. You want it silky and flowing, not stringy or lumpy.
- 5. Putting It All Together
- Mix the bacon into your cheese sauce first, then add pasta. This spreads it evenly through the whole dish. Dunk each chicken strip in honey pepper sauce, letting extra drip away. Scoop pasta into bowls, place glazed chicken on top, and finish with fresh basil and extra black pepper.
Pin it
Our family trick for knockout cheese sauce is adding just a tiny bit of nutmeg - it boosts the cheese flavor without anyone noticing it's there. After trying so many versions, this little trick really made everything click.
Heat Control Matters
Getting temperatures right changes everything in this dish. Start with furiously boiling water for pasta, keep oil steady at 350°F for crisp chicken, and never let cheese sauce bubble. Give chicken a 5-minute rest at room temp before saucing or it'll slide right off. Watch the honey pepper mix like a hawk while it reduces to nail that perfect thickness.
Pin it
Prep Work Shortcuts
Getting everything ready first saves stress. Shred cheese while waiting for water to boil, cook bacon beforehand, and measure honey pepper sauce ingredients into cups. This planning stops cheese sauce from breaking or pasta turning mushy. Pour liquids into easy-tipping containers to make sauce-making smoother.
Do-Ahead Options
Make parts separately for quick assembly later. Cook bacon and mix up honey pepper sauce up to three days early. Warm cheese sauce slowly with a splash of cream when needed. Cook pasta slightly firm if you'll reheat it later. Keep chicken pieces uncovered in the fridge to stay crispy.
Ways to Serve
Bring it to the table on one big platter or in separate bowls. Top with fresh basil, extra bacon bits, and a drizzle of warm honey pepper sauce. Enjoy right away while cheese sauce is hot and runny. Keep some extra sauce warm so folks can add more if they want.
Storing Extras Properly
Keep parts separate - pasta with cheese sauce in one container, chicken in another. Warm pasta mix over low heat with a splash of cream. Perk up chicken in a 350°F oven for 5-7 minutes to bring back the crunch. Mix fresh honey pepper sauce since stored stuff gets too thick.
Pin it
Wrapping Up
This fancy mac and cheese turns a popular restaurant staple into something special you can make at home. The mix of perfectly cooked pasta, rich cheese sauce, crispy chicken, and that trademark honey pepper glaze makes a meal that's both familiar and exciting. The secret to getting it right is taking your time with each part and watching temperatures carefully.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Is store-bought shredded cheese okay?
- Freshly grated works way better. The packaged kind has additives that mess up how smoothly it melts.
- → Can I cook this beforehand?
- You can make the sauces early but mix everything right before serving. The cheese mix might break apart when warmed again.
- → Will this burn my mouth?
- It's just a bit warm from the cayenne. You can add more or less pepper to match what you like.
- → Can other pasta shapes work?
- Any medium-sized pasta does the job. Curly shapes grab more sauce in their twists.
- → What if I don't have pineapple juice?
- Try orange juice or apple juice instead, but the taste will be a little different.