Pin it
Campfire memories burst to life in these mouthwatering S'mores Cookies. Every mouthful delivers that perfect mix of soft cookie base, gooey chocolate, and golden marshmallows, making a treat you can enjoy all year that brings back those fun outdoor moments.
I started baking these for my boy's scout meetings last year, and now they want them every time. There's something wonderful about watching those marshmallows turn golden under the broiler, just like they would over an open flame.
Key Ingredients Breakdown
- Butter: Go for unsalted that's slightly softened - it should dent a little when you push it
- Graham Crackers: Make sure they're fresh and crunchy; old ones can taste weird
- Chocolate: Pick good quality milk chocolate bars that melt well, such as Hershey's or Ghirardelli
- Marshmallows: The tiny ones spread better through the cookie and melt faster
Pin it
Step-by-Step Making Process
- Getting The Cookie Foundation Right
- Beat butter and sugars till they're super fluffy, around 3-4 minutes
- Put in eggs one by one, mixing completely after each
- Stop mixing right when the flour disappears so cookies stay soft
- Making Sure They Turn Out Right
- Cool the dough until it feels firm when touched
- Grab a cookie scoop for same-sized cookies
- Make sure to space them well apart on the tray
- Finishing Them Perfectly
- Add toppings fast while cookies are still hot
- Keep your eyes on them during broiling - marshmallows burn fast
- Wait for cookies to cool totally before you stack them
Pin it
When I was little, making s'mores was the best part of our family camping trips. These cookies bring those good times back while helping me create new ones at home.
This has turned into our go-to baking project when it's raining outside, letting us enjoy that summer camping taste whenever we want.
The amazing thing about these cookies is how they take a simple campfire snack and turn it into something you'd be proud to bring to any party.
It's the mix of different feels - soft cookie, crispy graham crackers, and sticky marshmallow - that makes them so hard to resist.
After making batch after batch and feeding lots of happy friends, these s'mores cookies have shown they're the best way to enjoy campfire flavors in a handy cookie form.
Tasty Presentation Ideas
Make these cookies extra special by serving them a bit warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. For get-togethers, I've made "s'mores cookie sandwiches" by putting chocolate ice cream between two cooled cookies. During the holidays, try adding a little caramel sauce on top for something truly special.
Pin it
Keeping Them Fresh
These cookies taste best when eaten within three days, but you can make them last by:
- Putting raw dough balls in the freezer for up to 3 months
- Placing baked cookies in stacks with wax paper between
- Storing them in sealed containers away from dampness and warmth
Different Season Twists
Summer: Mix in crushed freeze-dried strawberries for extra flavor
Fall: Add a dash of cinnamon to the dough
Winter: Sprinkle crushed peppermint candy on top
Spring: Try using white chocolate and pink marshmallows
Fixing Common Problems
If marshmallows melt too far, try putting them right in the middle of each cookie. When cookies flatten too much, chill the dough longer or add a tablespoon more flour. If your chocolate isn't melting well, try cutting it into smaller pieces.
Planning Ahead
Get ready for parties by:
- Making your dough up to 2 days before
- Getting all toppings measured and ready
- Setting out your baking tools ahead of time
- Creating a spot for cookies to cool
More Than Just Tasty
Great way to spend time with family
Fun way to teach kids about baking
Makes memories that last
Helps learn patience through waiting and careful toasting
My little girl once told me these cookies taste like "summer hugs," and that's so true. Just making them pulls our family together much like sitting around a campfire does.
After tweaking this recipe for years, I've found the real special part isn't just the familiar s'mores flavor, but how these cookies bring folks together. Whether you share them at a birthday party or pack them for an outing, they always make people smile and create sweet moments. Just remember, cookies taste best when they're made with love and shared with friends!
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Why should I chill the dough?
- It helps stop the cookies from spreading too much and boosts flavor.
- → Is freezing these cookies possible?
- Absolutely! Keep baked cookies without toppings frozen for up to 3 months.
- → Can I prep the dough earlier?
- For sure! Pop it in the fridge for 3 days or freeze it for 3 months.
- → Do marshmallows have to be toasted?
- Nope! It’s totally up to you. Toasting gives it that authentic taste.
- → What’s the best way to store them?
- Use an airtight container, and they’ll stay fresh on the counter for about 5 days.