Pin it
Make your childhood favorite at home with these simple pizza bagels. Using top-notch ingredients and the right method, you'll get crunchy edges, gooey cheese, and authentic pizza taste in every mouthful. They're way tastier than frozen ones and just as handy, making them great for fast dinners or party snacks.
After trying many batches, I've found that good toasting and not going overboard with toppings gives you the best results.
Key Ingredients
- Bagels: Plain or everything flavors are your best bet
- Pizza Sauce: Should be thick and flavorful (½ cup in total)
- Mozzarella: Grate it yourself (8 oz)
- Mini Pepperoni: Just the right size for bagel tops
- Italian Seasonings: Boosts the taste
- Fresh Basil: Add after cooking for garnish
Step-by-Step Guide
- 1. Get Your Bagels Ready:
- Cut bagels in half across the middle, then toast the cut parts under the broiler for 1-2 minutes until they're slightly golden. This helps keep them from getting mushy. Let them cool a bit before adding your toppings. Move your oven rack to the middle and heat it to 400°F regular bake.
- 2. Add Your Sauce:
- Put 1 tablespoon of pizza sauce on each bagel half, leaving a small edge around the outside. Don't go crazy with sauce or you'll end up with soggy bagels. Sprinkle a bit of Italian herbs on each one.
- 3. Put On Toppings:
- Scatter 2 tablespoons of mozzarella over the sauce. Don't pile on too many toppings or the cheese won't melt right. If you're using pancetta, cook it till it's crisp first. For pepperoni lovers, 5-6 mini slices work great on each half.
- 4. Bake Them Up:
- Set your topped bagels on a baking sheet lined with parchment paper. Bake for 10-12 minutes until the cheese melts and bubbles with some golden spots. Keep an eye on them after 8 minutes so they don't burn.
- 5. Finishing Touches:
- Cool for 2-3 minutes before eating. This helps the cheese firm up a bit and prevents mouth burns. Toss on some fresh basil if you'd like.
Pin it
Keeping and Serving Tips
Make sure the bagels cool all the way before you put them away. For meal planning, they'll stay good in a sealed container for up to 3 days. To freeze them, place your assembled but uncooked bagels on a tray and freeze until hard, about 2 hours. Then pack them in freezer bags for up to 3 months. When you're ready to eat, cook them straight from frozen, just add 2-3 more minutes to the cooking time.
Great Side Dishes
- Simple green salad
- Extra marinara for dipping
- Homemade garlic knots
- Caesar salad
- Raw veggie platter
- Ranch dressing
Tasty Twists
- BBQ Chicken: Cooked chicken, BBQ sauce, sliced red onions
- Mediterranean: Black olives, crumbled feta, wilted spinach
- Buffalo Style: Hot sauce, shredded chicken, drizzled ranch
- Margherita: Sliced fresh mozzarella, tomato slices, basil leaves
- Supreme: Chopped peppers, diced onions, sliced olives, cooked sausage
Pin it
These homemade pizza bagels show that basic ingredients can make something really tasty. Whether you're feeding hungry kids after school or having friends over, they'll bring back old memories while making new ones. Just remember, proper prep and not overdoing the toppings will get you perfect results every time.
Pin it
Closing Thoughts
Getting pizza bagels just right comes down to balancing what goes on top and using the right methods. Toasting them first stops sogginess, while carefully arranging toppings ensures everything cooks evenly. Each time you make them is a chance to get better and create your own special version of this much-loved snack.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Which bagels should I use?
- Any bagels work fine - plain or everything bagels taste great, but pick whatever you like.
- → Can I switch up the toppings?
- Absolutely! Try veggies, different meat options, or keep it super simple with just cheese on top.
- → How do I keep the bagels crispy?
- Go light on the sauce and toast fresh bagels before adding toppings.
- → Can I prepare these beforehand?
- Definitely! Put them together and stick them in the freezer for up to a month. Bake them frozen when you need them.
- → What's the best way to warm up extras?
- Warm them in a 350°F oven until the cheese gets bubbly. Don't use the microwave if you want them to stay crispy.